What Are We Really Comparing?

Before we get into pros and cons, let's clarify what we mean by each type.

Traditional Locks

When we say traditional locks, we're talking about physical deadbolts and keyed entry locks. These range from basic builder-grade hardware you'll find at big box stores to high-security options like Medeco or Mul-T-Lock that resist picking, drilling, and bumping. The key difference? They all require a physical key to operate.

Think of your typical deadbolt on a Back Bay condo or the keyed entry on a Jamaica Plain triple-decker. No batteries, no Wi-Fi, no app. Just metal, pins, and a key.

Smart Locks

Smart locks are electronic locks that let you unlock your door without a traditional key. Most work through a phone app, keypad code, or fingerprint reader. Some still have a physical keyhole as backup, while others are fully keyless.

The technology varies widely. Some simply replace your existing deadbolt and connect to your phone via Bluetooth. Others integrate with full home automation systems, sending you alerts when someone comes home and automatically locking when you leave.

The Real Advantages of Smart Locks

Smart locks solve specific problems really well. Here's where they genuinely make life easier:

No More Key Juggling

This is the big one. When your hands are full, you unlock your door with a code or your phone. Coming home from Whole Foods in Cambridge with six bags? Just punch in your code. Walking your dog in Brookline Village? Your phone's already in your pocket.

We've installed smart locks for busy parents who got tired of digging for keys while holding a sleeping toddler. For them, it's been life-changing.

Remote Access Actually Matters

Remember that contractor scenario from earlier? With a smart lock, you can unlock your door from anywhere. Let in a dog walker while you're at work. Give your house cleaner access on Tuesdays only. Lock up if you forgot before leaving for vacation.

One Newton family we work with has college-age kids who come home randomly. Instead of hiding keys or coordinating schedules, they just give them temporary codes. When the semester ends, they delete the codes. Simple.

You Always Know What's Happening

Most smart locks track when your door is locked or unlocked, and by whom. This isn't about paranoia - it's about peace of mind. You're lying in bed wondering if you locked the front door? Check your app. Want to know when your teenager got home? You'll get a notification.

For families with older kids or Airbnb hosts in Boston's tight rental market, this feature alone justifies the upgrade.

No More Rekeying After Lost Keys

Lost your keys? With a traditional lock, you're calling us to rekey your locks. With a smart lock? Just delete that person's code and create a new one. Takes about 30 seconds.

Same goes for fired employees, ended relationships, or when you stop trusting that you gave your spare key to. Just revoke their access.

Where Smart Locks Fall Short

Now let's talk about the stuff the ads don't mention:

Batteries Die at the Worst Times

Every smart lock runs on batteries. Most will warn you weeks in advance when they're getting low, but people ignore warnings. We've gotten emergency calls from homeowners locked out because their batteries died and they never installed the backup key cylinder.

Good smart locks include low-battery alerts and typically last 6-12 months. But you have to actually change the batteries when prompted. It's one more thing to remember, like changing your smoke detector batteries.

Boston Weather Is Rough on Electronics

We install locks year-round across Greater Boston, which means we see what happens when temperatures swing from 95 degrees in July to 5 degrees in January. Electronics don't love that.

Most quality smart locks handle New England weather fine, but cheaper models can freeze up or glitch in extreme cold. We've learned which brands hold up and which ones cause problems. Location matters too - a lock on an exposed porch in Brighton faces different conditions than one in a protected alcove in Beacon Hill.

The Learning Curve Is Real

Traditional locks are intuitive. Turn key, door opens. Smart locks require setup, app downloads, Wi-Fi passwords, and sometimes integration with other systems. For tech-savvy folks, no problem. For others, it's frustrating.

We've had customers in their 70s who love their smart locks, and 30-year-olds who returned them after a week. It's not about age - it's about patience with technology.

Internet Problems Mean Lock Problems

Most smart locks work fine without internet - you can still use your keypad or phone via Bluetooth. But you lose remote access. If your Wi-Fi is down, you can't unlock the door from work. If your phone dies, you better hope you set up that backup key.

These aren't dealbreakers, but they're realities that traditional locks simply don't have.

Why Traditional Locks Still Make Sense

Here's what traditional locks do better:

They're Completely Reliable

A quality traditional deadbolt like a Medeco or Schlage just works. No batteries, no software updates, no connectivity issues. Install it once, and it'll function perfectly for decades.

We still service locks from the 1980s that work flawlessly. Try that with any electronic device.

Maximum Security Without Compromise

The most secure locks available are still traditional. High-security cylinders from Medeco and Mul-T-Lock offer pick resistance, drill resistance, and key control that smart locks can't match yet.

If you're genuinely concerned about someone defeating your lock through skill rather than brute force, top-tier traditional locks are still your best bet.

Lower Cost, No Ongoing Hassles

A professional-grade traditional deadbolt costs less upfront and has zero recurring costs. No batteries to buy, no subscriptions to maintain, no replacing the unit when new tech comes out.

For straightforward home security without monthly thinking about it, traditional locks win.

Perfect for Historic Boston Homes

Many Boston-area homes are historic. Brownstones in South End, Victorians in Somerville, colonials in Lexington. These homes often have specific aesthetic requirements or historical society guidelines.

Traditional locks come in styles that maintain period-appropriate appearance while providing modern security. Smart locks... generally look like smart locks.

When You Should Choose a Smart Lock

Smart locks make the most sense if you:

• Frequently have people coming and going (contractors, dog walkers, cleaners, Airbnb guests)
• Want to monitor when kids come home from school
• Regularly have your hands full when arriving home
• Already have or plan to build a smart home system
• Are comfortable troubleshooting basic tech issues
• Value convenience over absolute simplicity

We've seen smart locks transform daily routines for busy families in Newton and Brookline. The ability to create temporary codes for contractors or get notifications when elderly parents leave the house brings genuine peace of mind.

When You Should Stick with Traditional

Traditional locks are the better choice if you:

• Want maximum security without any potential electronic vulnerabilities
• Prefer set-it-and-forget-it reliability
• Don't have regular visitors who need access
• Live in a historic home with aesthetic requirements
• Get frustrated by tech that requires regular attention
• Want the lowest total cost of ownership

For many homeowners across Boston, Cambridge, and surrounding towns, a high-quality traditional lock provides everything they need without any of the complications they don't want.

The Middle Ground: Hybrid Approach

Here's something most people don't consider: you can mix and match.

Many Boston homeowners we work with use a smart lock on their main entrance for convenience and traditional deadbolts on back doors and garage entries. This gives you the benefits of smart technology where you use it most, with the reliability and security of traditional locks everywhere else.

It's also a good way to test smart lock technology without fully committing. Put one on your front door. If you love it after six months, consider expanding. If not, you haven't replaced every lock in your house.

What About Security?

This is the question we get most: are smart locks actually secure?

The honest answer: yes, if you buy quality brands and use them properly. No, if you buy cheap ones or configure them carelessly.

Quality smart locks from established manufacturers have strong encryption and regular security updates. The vulnerability usually isn't the lock itself - it's weak passwords, shared codes with too many people, or not changing default settings.

Meanwhile, traditional locks can be picked, bumped, or defeated with the right tools and knowledge. The reality is that most break-ins happen through windows or unlocked doors anyway, not through sophisticated lock picking.

Both types can be secure. Both can be insecure. It depends on the specific product and how you use it.

Professional Installation Matters More Than You Think

Whether you choose smart or traditional, proper installation makes the difference between a lock that protects your home and one that's just decorative.

We see DIY installations every week that look fine but have serious issues. Misaligned strike plates. Improperly set smart lock calibrations. Screws that are too short. Locks installed in doors that aren't thick enough to support them properly.

Boston's housing stock ranges from brand new construction to buildings pushing 200 years old. Installing locks in a modern Seaport condo is different from installing them in a Charlestown townhouse with its third set of replacement doors. A professional locksmith knows how to handle these variations.

For smart locks especially, professional installation ensures everything works correctly from day one. We'll make sure your lock is calibrated properly, test all the features, set up backup access methods, and show you how everything works. Plus, if something goes wrong later, you have someone to call who knows your exact setup.

Making Your Decision

So which should you choose? Start by asking yourself these questions:

Do you regularly let people into your home when you're not there?

If yes, smart locks make this much easier. If no, you probably don't need that feature.

How do you feel about managing technology?

Enjoy it? Smart locks will feel natural. Find it draining? Traditional locks won't add stress to your life.

What's your biggest security concern?

Worried about physical break-ins? Both types work. Concerned about digital vulnerabilities? Traditional wins. Want to know exactly who's coming and going? Smart locks provide that visibility.

What's your home style?

Modern home with other smart devices? Smart locks integrate nicely. Historic property? Traditional locks maintain the aesthetic while providing security.

The Bottom Line

There's no universal right answer. Smart locks solve real problems for people who need remote access, have frequent visitors, or want activity monitoring. Traditional locks provide bulletproof reliability, maximum security options, and zero ongoing attention.

What matters most is choosing the right lock for your specific situation and having it installed properly.

At Astro Locks, we install both types every day across Greater Boston. We've seen what works in Brookline apartments, Newton single-families, Cambridge condos, and everything in between. Sometimes we recommend smart locks. Sometimes we recommend traditional. Sometimes we suggest a combination.

If you're trying to decide what's right for your home, we're happy to walk you through your options based on your actual needs, not what's trendy or what earns us the highest margin. Good security isn't about the newest technology or the oldest traditions - it's about what actually protects your family and property while fitting your lifestyle.

Want to discuss which type of lock makes sense for your Boston-area home? Contact Astro Locks for a free consultation. We'll help you make the right choice - whether that's smart, traditional, or somewhere in between.